3.3 BF Skinner
Burrhus Frederic (B F) Skinner is one of the key figures in psychology, most notably within the influential behaviourist movement. In a vociferous quest to place psychology on a scientific footing, behaviourists discard introspectionist concepts such as human nature, personality development and even personality itself. They exist, of course, but psychology can only be scientific, according to the behaviourist perspective, if restricted to observable factors and visible operations performed on the organism from without. The organism might as well be empty. Behaviourists also reject the fundamental humanistic-existential concept of free will (see Section II), this similarly occurring in the irrelevant “black box” betweenstimulus and response, between input and output, between environmental conditions and observable reaction to those conditions. Similarly, and controversially, Skinner contends that even human beings cannot and do not plan for the future.
Instead of saying that a man behaves because of the consequences which are to follow his behaviour, simply say that he behaves because of the consequences which have followed similar behaviour in the past. (Skinner, 1953: 87)
All behaviour and psychological development is stated categorically to be determined by prior conditioning, especially operant conditioning. Operant conditioning focuses upon the consequences of a person’s behaviour as he proactively “operates” upon his environment. The consequences generated by his behaviour will clearly affect the subsequent frequency, intensity and duration of similar behaviour. Skinner identifies four consequence scenarios: positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement, punishment and operant extinction.
Positive reinforcement strengthens a behaviour by rewarding it. Skinner distinguishes between primary reinforcement, which satisfies a basic need (e.g. food, drink, shelter), and secondary reinforcement, which rewards through its learned association with a primary (e.g. money, attention, approval). Negative reinforcement, despite its label, similarly strengthens a behaviour. This occurs through the removal, reduction or prevention of an unpleasant experience. Examples are taking painkillers and obeying the law, both of which stave off negative consequences and are hence reinforced. Negative reinforcement may also account for self-protection in relationships and the perpetuation of a phobic response. In the latter case, the person’s avoidance of the phobic situation or object precludes a negative outcome – the phobic response itself – and is hence reinforced. Unfortunately, such avoidance also prevents extinction of the phobic response from occurring, through classical conditioning principles, as it would were the person to approach and remain in the phobic situation. It is not inconceivable that positive and negative reinforcement apply more widely to human development.
Skinner is not a great fan of punishment, preferring to prescribe operant extinctionto diminish undesirable behaviour. Extinction is proposed to occur because the offending behaviour is not reinforced. It may, for instance, be ignored. The classic example is not engaging with a child’s temper tantrums so that they eventually settle down (rather than give the child attention, positively reinforcement his outbursts and make them even more resistant to extinction). Another is the time out procedure where the child is removed from the environment (e.g. the classroom) in which her undesirable behaviour has occurred and placed alone in another (e.g. the corridor) where no reinforcement is available. In general, Skinner advocates the benefits of positive reinforcement to enhance desirable behaviour and operant extinction to reduce undesirable behaviour. He wrote extensively about creating an ideal society based upon such contingencies of reinforcement.
Skinner emphasises another axis of reinforcement: continuous reinforcement and partial reinforcement. Continuous reinforcement is problematical in that it risks satiation. A child might become sick of receiving a chocolate bar, for instance, every time that she makes her bed. Partial reinforcement is more realistic. We do not receive praise for every job that we do, for example, nor do we win every bet that we place. The increase in response rate and resistance to extinction evoked by partial reinforcement is reflected in the everyday statement “treat ’em mean, keep ’em keen”. Skinner identified four different schedules of partial reinforcement, after serendipitously running short of food pellets which he used to rewards rats and pigeons in his standard Skinner box apparatus.
With a fixed interval schedule, the person is rewarded after a set time period (or, more correctly, for the first target response after the time period has elapsed) – typical of, say, salaried employment. In fixed ratio, he is rewarded after completing a set number of target responses, exemplified by piecework. The fixed schedules, especially the latter, may produce a lull in responding after the reward has been administered. Such “rest periods” are avoided by variable schedules, where receiving the reinforcement becomes unpredictable. A variable intervalschedule provides the reward after an irregular interval, though a set time period on average. Hence. a so-called VI5 schedule rewards on average every five minutes, but the specific intervals might range between fifteen seconds and fifteen minutes. The recreational activity of fishing could fit into this variable interval framework. A variable ratio schedule provides the reward after an unpredictable number of target responses. Hence, a VR5 schedule rewards every five responses, but the specific number of responses required might range from, say, one to 15. Gambling and other addictions might fit into this variable ratio framework.
The main findings regarding partial reinforcement schedules which could influence human psychological development as follows.
· Behaviour is more easily acquired through continuous reinforcement, but more easily maintained by partial reinforcement.
· Behaviour subject to partial reinforcement is more resistant to extinction. The Skinnerian advice to those wishing to break an undesirable habit, therefore, is not to yield to temptation since this would put the behaviour on to a partial reinforcement schedule.
· Ratio schedules lead to higher response rates than do interval schedules since the organism can influence the provision of reinforcement.
· Variable schedules generate a more constant response rate and slower extinction than do fixed schedules as each response has a chance of being rewarded.
Other phenomena of operant conditioning include generalisation, discrimination and shaping. In generalisation, the organism learns to perform similar behaviour to that specifically reinforced and to do so in similar situations. A infant, for example, might say “Da- Da” to all men and not just to her father. Withdiscrimination, the organism learns only to respond when a discriminative stimulusis present. Thus, a pigeon in the Skinner box learns to peck a disk only when a light is present to indicate that a food pellet reward is available. It does not peck when the light is off. Similarly, a person will tend only to ask an onerous favour of his partner when she appears to be in a good mood. Shaping involves reinforcingsuccessive approximations to the desired response and extinguishing everything else. It is the basis of all animal training. In accordance with general process learning theory, however, Skinner and other behaviourists argue that the laws of learning are consistent between species and, thereby, apply to human beings too. In this respect, Skinner also noted superstitious behaviour – namely, that exhibited at the time a reward is given – itself becoming reinforced, often in a single trial.
Additional pointers for self-control advised by Skinner include:
· stimulus control (e.g. removing oneself from the situation which triggers one’s undesirable reaction)
· self-administered satiation (e.g. overdoing an unwanted behaviour to utilise, in everyday terms, principles of diminishing returns and “too much of a good thing . . .”)
· aversive stimulation (e.g. setting up potentially unpleasant consequences such as the loss of face that could result from broadcasting to friends that one is about to make a behavioural change and then failing to do so)
· self-reinforcement (e.g. rewarding oneself for desirable behaviours).
Behaviour itself is quantified and assessed by Skinner through functional analysesof its frequency, context and reinforcement using direct observation, self-reports (e.g. interviews or questionnaires) and physiological measurements (e.g. of muscular tension, heart rate or brain wave patterns). All of the principles delineated above form the basis of behaviour modification, not only a tried and tested approach to therapy but also a cogent account of some of the processes affecting human psychological development.
Skinner, B F (1938). The Behaviour of Organisms: An Experimental Analysis. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Skinner, B F (1948). Walden Two. New York: MacMillan.
Skinner, B F (1953). Science and Human Behaviour. New York: MacMillan.
Skinner, B F (1957). Verbal Behaviour. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Skinner, B F (1968). The Technology of Teaching. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Skinner, B F (1969). Contingencies of Reinforcement: A Theoretical Analysis. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Skinner, B F (1971). Beyond Freedom and Dignity. New York: Knopf.
Skinner, B F (1972). Cumulative Record: A Selection of Papers (3rd edition). New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Skinner, B F (1974). About Behaviourism. New York: Knopf.
Skinner, B F (1977). Particulars of my Life. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Skinner, B F (1978). Reflections on Behaviourism and Society. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Skinner, B F (1984). Intellectual Self-management in Old Age. American Psychologist, 38: 239-244.
Skinner, B F (1986). The Shame of American Education. American Psychologist, 41: 568-574.
Skinner, B F (1987). Upon Further Reflection. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Some webpages on Skinner:
We have been training professionals for 40 consecutive years (Longer than any other organisation in the UK). Many of the top therapists and trainers in the UK began their career at the National College.
Our complete Diploma Course is a genuine, validated post graduate programme (ADHP recipients are eligible for direct entry to the MA in Counselling and Psychotherapy Practice at Bath Spa University with 90 Credits APL).
We are 100% committed to the highest standards of training so that you are fully prepared for the challenges of professional practice
The National College is the only UK training organisation which is authorised the offer the European Certificate of Clinical Hypnosis through the European Association for Hypno-Psychotherapy. We are also one of only two European Accredited Psychotherapy Training Institutes with the European Association for Psychotherapy We should really be the International College of Hypnosis and Psychotherapy as we have graduates all over the world. We are an outward thinking organisation which looks out to the world for opportunities. Our Principal is the International Officer of UKCP and its representative to the Board of the EAP. We will continue to engage to ensure that our graduates have a future in a post-Brexit Europe.
Within the National College we have a philosophy that ensures that all tutors are full-time practitioners in addition to their training. By this we mean that they derive their primary income from seeing clients: this ensures that they "walk the walk" as well as "talk the talk". You will find that we often have examples of current clients to tell you about that illustrate theoretical points. There are some trainers who set up a school because they can't make it as practitioners. Would you want to be trained by them?
We believe it is vitally important that you see demonstrations of techniques and also get to practice. This gives you the confidence to practice with "real people" as soon as (if not before) you qualify. We say before, because you will be given permission to work with certain issues at certain points in your training. Not all trainers demonstrate, and not all give you a chance to practice and build your confidence.(ALL ours DO!)
On completion of the certificate course (stage two), graduates can join a range of professional bodies: the Complementary and Natural Healthcare Council (our regulator), the National Council for Hypnotherapy (a members’ co-operative with high standards, of which both our Principal and Managing Director are former chairs) and our own National Society of Hypnosis, Psychotherapy & Mindfulness. All you need to set up in professional practice with great support!
The National College course leads to registration with the UK Council for Psychotherapy; it is essential that important that your career is protected by being registered with a leading professional association like the UKCP (requirements for registration are laid out here). Our Managing Director is an Honorary Fellow of UKCP (approx. 1% of registrants) and is chair of the UKCP Education, Training and Practice Committee. Through this link you can be sure that we keep at the forefront of all developments in the field.
We believe in creating a friendly learning environment in which students feel safe to express themselves and learn while building supportive peer relationships with fellow students.
All our tutors are experienced teachers, as well as being, themselves, National College trained and experienced practitioners. We have made it policy that all tutors have to demonstrate training in diversity.
Support from a long established well-staffed organisation throughout not only your training but also your whole career!
We actively enforce equal opportunities and other policies
We believe the learning environment should be a safe, confidential and supportive space for all learners. For this reason we are committed to actively enforcing all our equal opportunities policies by making reasonable adjustments for any of the legally defined protected characteristics. An example of a reasonable adjustment would be agreeing to allow a student with dyslexia to provide portfolio evidence in recorded rather than written form if they needed to do so.
We encourage students to ask questions or make comments about the training at any stage and will do our best to meet your needs. There is a student representative on the Academic Board.
Ethical considerations are all important in a field where one is working with vulnerable people. We cover these in depth. Check with other schools as to which, if any, code of ethics they subscribe. They should be bound by a training code of ethics as well as teaching you one for practice.
The National College embraces modern technology; we provide our materials on a Kindle so that you have all that you need at your fingertips. Additionally, we are one of the first institutes in our field to use "online directed learning" as part of our advanced training.
We know that you want to know exactly what you will be learning, so we publish all the details of the structure of our courses including detailed learning outcomes. We also publish our external accreditation reports from UKCP, you can read our latest one here We want you to be sure you have made the right choice!
We train small groups of students, which we believe is important so that you get individual attention. Some schools have as many as 50 students in a class! We are also not limited to training in one location. We currently run courses in London, Manchester, Oxford and East Midlands (Leicester) in the UK and the Gold Coast (Australia) and Phoenix Arizona (USA)
Past students are welcome to re-attend any stage of their training FREE OF CHARGE (subject to available space) in the ten years following their primary training. This is just one of the ways we support our students. We believe that we are the only school of our type to offer this opportunity free of charge.
National College Hypnosis Training and Hypnotherapy Training courses adhere to the National Occupational Standards for Hypnotherapy (the Principal and Managing Director were members of the working group who wrote these), and incorporate and Professional Occupational Standards produced by UKCP.
We do not take just anyone onto our courses. You will be interviewed to ensure that you are suitable for this profession of working with vulnerable people, and, very importantly, to ensure that the National College is right for you. If we feel that another course would be better for you (and this does happen), we will tell you, and advise you of who to approach.
Therapy is an "individual" process: we will encourage you to find your own way to be the best therapist you can be.
Our course also includes business/practice management. So often hypnotherapists and psychotherapists fall at the first hurdle because, while they may be wonderful at what they do, they don't know how to get the clients. The National College has a great depth of knowledge and experience in this area that you can draw on. All our tutors around the country are willing to share with you what works and what doesn't so that you can learn from our successes, and our mistakes!
Our complete Diploma Course is a genuine, validated post graduate programme (ADHP recipients are eligible for direct entry to the MA in Counselling and Psychotherapy Practice at Bath Spa University with 90 Credits APL.